As I said in my post last September 27th, the batteries in both my key fobs were in excess of 3V. The other curious thing was that both key fobs were rejected after the same time (independently) even though one had been used much more than the other. It makes me think the timing is set by the car and not the state of the key fob at all. That way VW will get to charge a proportion of owners over the odds for replacing them.